Summary
Week 4 invited us to
challenge the long-standing separation between mathematics and the arts.
Drawing on C.P. Snow’s idea of the “Two Cultures,” the course introduction
highlighted how mathematics and artistic ways of knowing have often been
positioned as opposites, despite their shared history. Historically,
disciplines such as music, geometry, astronomy, and arithmetic were deeply
connected, forming part of the classical liberal arts. Many non-Western
knowledge systems, including Indigenous ways of knowing such as Two-Eyed
Seeing, continue to resist this divide by holding scientific, artistic, and
spiritual understandings together.
This week also introduced the Bridges Math + Art community as a contemporary example of this integration, showcasing how mathematics can be expressed through visual art, music, movement, and play. My reading, Make Music Visible, Play Mathematics by Capozucca and Fermani, reinforced this perspective by showing how mathematical and musical understanding emerges through hands-on, multisensory experiences. Rather than focusing solely on counting or ratios, the authors emphasize geometry, structure, and transformation, noting that “mathematics is about structure and pattern.” This framing resonated strongly with my experiences in classrooms and school leadership, where learning is often most powerful when it is embodied and relational.
Stop 1: Sound and
Movement as the First Patterns
As I read about the
music-geometry workshop described in the article, I was reminded of an early
years lesson I taught with a group of Kindergarten and Grade 1 students during
an introductory patterning unit. Instead of beginning with visual patterns, we
started with sound and movement patterns. We explored repeating
sequences using clapping and stomping, gradually building more complex patterns
together.
What we noticed was that when the whole group participated simultaneously, the classroom began to sound like music. The students were not labeling AB or ABB patterns, but they were experiencing rhythm, repetition, and structure in an embodied way. This experience closely mirrors Capozucca and Fermani’s approach, where understanding emerges through listening, movement, and collective participation. It reinforced for me that mathematical thinking does not need to begin with symbols or definitions; it can begin with the body.
Stop 2: Playful
Mathematics Through Sound and Drawing (Vi Hart)
The short Vi Hart
videos, Möbius Music Box, Sound Braid, and Doodle Music, extended this idea of embodied mathematical play. These videos present
mathematics through doodling, looping, rhythm, and sound, allowing patterns to
emerge organically rather than through formal instruction. What stood out to me
was how mathematical ideas such as repetition, symmetry, transformation, and
variation were experienced rather than explained.
In Sound Braid and Doodle Music, simple visual marks transform into rhythmic structures, blurring the boundaries between drawing, music, and mathematics. This playful exploration aligns strongly with the reading, which argues that learners develop deeper understanding when they are given space to experiment and discover patterns for themselves. Watching these videos reinforced my belief that curiosity and play are powerful entry points into mathematical thinking, especially when learners are allowed to engage multiple senses at once.
Stop 3: Multiple
Perspectives and Making Numbers Audible
My third stop
connected back to the TED Talk from Week 1, where the speaker demonstrated
multiple ways of representing the fraction 4/3, including using sound. At the
time, I shared this idea with my school staff during a discussion about
perspectives. What resonated most with them was how a single number could be
understood in many different ways depending on how it was represented.
Revisiting this idea
through the lens of Week 4 strengthened my understanding of why representation
matters. Just as music, geometry, and movement can offer new ways to understand
mathematical ideas, taking multiple perspectives allows us to see the “whole”
more clearly. My staff appreciated how this metaphor extended beyond
mathematics and into our work with students. To truly understand learners, we
must be willing to consider different viewpoints rather than relying on a
single narrative.
My final stop this
week came from noticing patterns in everyday school life. One Friday felt
particularly intense, behaviourally, the day resembled what staff often
jokingly refer to as a “full moon.” I spent much of the day managing situations
in the office, which left little time for anything else. One Grade 3 student in
particular stood out, a student with autism who is high-functioning and able
to communicate even when experiencing heightened frustration.
Over time, I have
noticed clear patterns when working with this student. If I can introduce
movement, walking, pacing, or physical activity, his emotional state begins
to shift. Recognizing this pattern led our school to purchase two small pieces
of exercise equipment: a stationary bike and a rowing machine. This decision
was grounded in the understanding that movement supports impulse control and
emotional regulation, not only for this student but likely for others in the
future.
This experience echoed the central message of Week 4. Whether we are observing patterns in mathematics, music, student behaviour, or nature, noticing patterns equips us to respond more effectively. When patterns are recognized, they become tools for problem-solving rather than challenges to manage.
Closing Reflection
Week 4 reinforced for
me that pattern is a unifying concept across disciplines and lived experiences.
Mathematics, music, learning, and behaviour are all shaped by our ability to
notice structure, rhythm, and repetition. When we attend to these patterns, through sound, movement, geometry, or observation , we are better equipped to
support learners, design responsive environments, and make thoughtful
decisions. Mathematics as art, music as structure, and behaviour as pattern all
remind me that learning is not confined to subject areas, but woven through the
everyday moments of teaching and leadership.
Resources – Week 4:
Mathematics and the Arts
Course &
Theoretical Framing
- Snow, C. P. (1959). The Two Cultures
and the Scientific Revolution. Cambridge University Press.
Bridges Math + Art
- Bridges Organization. (2022). Joint
Mathematics Meetings Art Exhibition.
https://gallery.bridgesmathart.org/exhibitions/2022-joint-mathematics-meetings
Reading
- Capozucca, A., & Fermani, M. (2019). Make
Music Visible, Play Mathematics. In Bridges 2019 Conference
Proceedings.
https://bridgesmathart.org/bridges-2019/
Videos
- Hart, V. (n.d.). Möbius Music Box.
- Hart, V. (n.d.). Sound Braid.
- Hart, V. (n.d.). Doodle Music.
(Vi Hart videos, available online)
TED Talk
- Strogatz, S. (2014). The joy of x
[TED Talk].
https://www.ted.com/talks/steven_strogatz_the_joy_of_x
(This is the talk
commonly used to explore multiple representations of mathematical ideas,
including using sound, rhythm, and visual metaphors to rethink familiar
concepts.)
I taught instrumental music for 4 years at my current site before switching to an all-core class schedule. Teaching music is an incredibly embody-ing job, and though they never realized it, many of my students engaged with on the daily. Looking back on it now that I've completed numerous courses in this cohort, there were so many opportunities for me to bridge the gap between curriculum mathematics and the things we were learning in music!
ReplyDeleteEspecially as a percussionist, I always tried to engage the fractional thinking of my drummers. Even the fraction that you mentioned--4/3--is incredibly important in many cultures music. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v8upXAChK-g Many of my black students would play this polyrhythm on the drums, as it is common in trap, hip-hop, Afro-Carribean, and African traditional music.
“What stood out to me was how mathematical ideas such as repetition, symmetry, transformation, and variation were experienced rather than explained.”
ReplyDeleteI had an aha! moment when I read this, Tracy! Vi Hart’s doodle music would be an unique way for my students to look at and experience transformations. That is a large component of their course work in grade 12. There are other art forms that lend themselves to experiencing repetition and symmetry, but I am really intrigued by this idea of using an auditory form to experience those aspects of mathematics. Thanks for sparking that thought!